Wall Street's Biggest Bull Is Calling Bottom. The Fed Might Not Agree.
Ed Yardeni says the S&P 500 selloff has gone too far and investors are panicking. The index is now in correction territory after a brutal 3.7% Friday drop. But the whole bull case still runs through the Federal Reserve, and that's a bet nobody controls.
I spent most of Friday afternoon watching the S&P 500 bleed and thinking about how fast sentiment flips.
A week ago the dip buyers were heroes. Now the index is in correction territory and everyone's a bear.
JUST IN: Ed Yardeni isn't buying it. Wall Street's most stubborn bull says the selloff has gone too far and investors are panicking too soon.
Maybe. But there's a catch, and it's sitting inside the Federal Reserve.
The 200-Day Line That Broke
Numbers first. The S&P dropped 3.7% on Friday. It's now more than 10% below its recent peak, which is the official line between a pullback and a correction. And the selling got loud right after the index lost its 200-day moving average.
That's not a coincidence.
A lot of money is wired to that line. Trend-following funds. CTAs. Risk-parity books. Vol-control strategies. These guys don't care whether Nvidia looks cheap. They follow rules. And the rules said cut exposure.
So they cut. Friday afternoon, with liquidity thinning out, that mechanical selling slams into bids that aren't there. Prices gap. Stops trigger. The drop feeds itself.
This changes things. Once the rule-based money finishes dumping, the market has to price fundamentals again. And right now fundamentals mean one thing.
Yardeni vs. the Fed
His call only works if the Fed gives him room. It falls apart if it doesn't.
Think about what's already baked in. Investors have spent months pricing rate cuts. That expectation is holding up the entire bull case, not just for stocks but for anything with duration. Crypto included. Bitcoin trades like a high-beta Nasdaq proxy on days like Friday, and that won't change while liquidity is the story.
So here's the question that actually matters. Does anyone honestly think the Fed cuts into a hot inflation print just because the S&P is down 10%?
If the data stays firm, cuts get pushed out. Multiples compress. Yardeni's "overreaction" turns into a slow grind lower instead of a clean V-shaped bounce.
The market's verdict won't come from a strategist's note. It'll come from the next CPI print and the next Fed meeting.
My Read
I'm not reflexively buying this dip, and neither should you.
Yardeni has earned the benefit of the doubt. He's been right through most of this bull run and fading him has been an expensive hobby. But corrections don't end because a respected voice says so. They end when sellers run out of shares.
What I'm watching is simple. Does the S&P reclaim that 200-day average within a couple of weeks? Fast reclaims have historically been noise. Long stays below it have historically been the opening act for something worse.
And just like that, a 3.7% Friday becomes a real test of conviction.
Position for both outcomes. Keep some dry powder. Don't chase the first green candle. Traders are watching closely, and so is the Fed.
Related Articles
Explore More
Key Terms Explained
An approval term meaning authentic, bold, or worthy of respect.
The first cryptocurrency, created in 2009 by the pseudonymous Satoshi Nakamoto.
A price decline of 10% or more from a recent high, but less than the 20% that defines a bear market.
The rate at which prices rise and money loses purchasing power.