VanEck Cuts Gemini From Three Crypto ETFs, Coinbase Keeps the Keys Until February 2027
VanEck is ending Gemini's custody role on three of its crypto ETFs, with Coinbase staying on as custodian through the February 2027 transition. It's a quiet procurement decision with a loud message about who actually controls the rails of the ETF trade.
VanEck just showed the entire ETF business how a custody breakup actually works. No press conference. No drama. A date on a calendar, and one name left standing.
Gemini is out on three VanEck crypto ETFs. Coinbase stays. The handoff lands in February 2027.
Read that again. February 2027. That's not a divorce. That's a lease running out.
Follow the Calendar
Here's the part people will skip past. A custody break with urgency attached means subpoenas, subpoenas mean lawyers, and lawyers mean the fund is already bleeding. None of that's happening here. VanEck gave the market a long runway and a clean line of sight to the exit. That's a request for proposal, not a rescue mission.
Think about what an issuer actually shops for when it picks a custodian. Insurance limits. Audit history. Cold storage architecture. Segregation of client assets. How fast a redemption settles at 4pm on a Friday when the market's puking. None of that's brand. None of that's vibes.
VanEck runs spot bitcoin and spot ether products in the US, and the third fund in this trio makes the pattern obvious. The firm isn't picking a custody partner per fund and letting chaos reign. It's consolidating. One operator, one set of processes, one throat to choke when something breaks.
And that consolidation cuts one direction only.
Coinbase already custodies the large majority of US spot crypto ETF assets. Estimates put its share somewhere in the high 70s to low 80s of a percent. BlackRock's product runs through it. Grayscale's runs through it. Now VanEck's stays. Every quarter that passes, the number gets a little more lopsided, and nobody at any of those issuers seems bothered by it.
My first hot take: Coinbase is becoming the AWS of crypto custody, and that's exactly as boring and exactly as lucrative as it sounds. Nobody picks AWS because they love the logo. They pick it because it's already there, it's already audited, and ripping it out costs more than the invoice.
My second, less comfortable take: this is bad for the asset class, and I say that as someone who thinks Coinbase has earned the business. Concentration cuts both ways. One custodian holding keys to most of the spot ETF market means one set of operational assumptions, one disaster recovery plan, one staffing bench, one set of insurance policies standing between a $100 billion category and a very ugly headline.
When one custodian holds the keys to most of the spot ETF market, what exactly is the diversification story you're telling your allocators?
The Case for Gemini
Now steelman the other side, because the reflexive read here's way too harsh.
Gemini custody isn't a startup side project. It runs under a New York trust charter, it does segregated cold storage, and it's spent the last two years pushing into Europe with a Malta license to serve the MiCA market. Losing three funds from one issuer doesn't sink that. Three funds is a line item.
And there's a real argument that these three VanEck products are small enough that Gemini's pricing was never going to win. Custody on a sub-scale fund is a spreadsheet exercise. If the assets aren't there, the fee pool isn't there, and the incumbent can always sharpen a pencil to keep the account.
Maybe this is just contract expiry. Maybe VanEck ran a review, and Gemini's bid came in a few basis points wide. Both firms are quiet about terms, which is normal, and neither is out there briefing against the other, which is also normal and honestly a good sign for how mature this corner of the market has gotten.
The counterpoint I actually buy is simpler. Custody deals die from attrition, not from catastrophe. Gemini keeps the consumer app, keeps the credit card, keeps the institutional trading desk. It just lost a slice of the boring middle. That's survivable.
What it isn't is neutral. Every fund that picks Coinbase makes the next fund's decision easier and cheaper. That's the flywheel, and it's spinning.
Here's the detail I'd watch: February 2027 is more than a year of transition. That's enough time to migrate keys, re-paper the trust documents, re-run the audits, and notify every counterparty twice. Firms don't budget that kind of runway for a relationship they might salvage. They budget it for one they've already decided to end.
Which means the decision is made. The announcement is just the paperwork catching up.
My Verdict
Coinbase wins this one and keeps winning it, and I don't think that's a close call.
Gemini is a fine custodian with real regulatory plumbing. But ETF issuers aren't shopping for fine. They're shopping for the vendor their compliance officer already signed off on last quarter. VanEck just walked that path in public, and every other issuer with a custody review on the books is going to read it the same way.
So the win column is obvious. The loss column is the one that should keep people up. A spot crypto ETF market with one dominant custodian is a market where operational risk stops being a line item and starts being a systemic one. Not because Coinbase is reckless, but because single points of failure don't care how competent the operator is.
And the next wave makes it worse. Spot Solana products are queuing up behind the bitcoin and ether launches, and whoever custodies that batch inherits the same lopsided math. If Coinbase ends up as custodian of record on most of them, the concentration conversation stops being theoretical and starts showing up in risk disclosures.
That's the real story hiding inside a quiet custody footnote. Not that VanEck left Gemini. That the industry keeps walking toward the same door.
The speed difference between crypto rails and TradFi rails isn't theoretical. You feel it. The key difference is now a whole lot more centralized than anyone wants to admit out loud.
Explore More
Key Terms Explained
The first cryptocurrency, created in 2009 by the pseudonymous Satoshi Nakamoto.
Following the laws and regulations that apply to financial activities, including crypto.
Who holds and controls your crypto assets.
Spreading investments across different assets to reduce risk.