Alphabet's 20% Slide Is a Valuation Story, Not a Chart Story
Google stock closed at $272.66 on November 19, down nearly 20% in a month and back near its cheapest valuation of 2025. Veteran chartist Larry Williams sees two signals a rally is building, but the real argument for Alphabet is the price, not the pattern.
Alphabet at $272.66 is the kind of number that gets value investors doing math in their heads. It's also the kind that gets chartists drawing lines. Pay attention to the first group, because the second group is telling you something, just not the thing that actually matters.
The Discount Is Real
Google stock has lost nearly 20% in a month, closing at $272.66 on November 19. That puts Alphabet back near its cheapest valuation of 2025, and it means roughly a fifth of the company's market value came off in four weeks. That's not a wobble. That's a repricing.
Larry Williams, the veteran chartist, sees two signs that a rally may be building. His track record is real, and technicians earned their keep in 2022 when the fundamentals looked fine right up until they didn't. But two signals on a chart won't tell you whether Search is holding its ground against AI answer engines. That's the only question that matters here, and no moving average answers it.
So here's the rhetorical one: is a 20% haircut on a company that still owns the most profitable advertising surface on earth a discount or a warning? Depends entirely on what you think Search looks like in three years.
The bear thesis isn't that the business is broken today. Advertising across Google's properties still brings in tens of billions every quarter at margins most CFOs would trade a limb for. The bear thesis is that people slowly stop typing into a search bar, and the repricing happens gradually enough that nobody panics until the revenue line flattens.
What the Skeptics Get Right
The skeptics have two solid arguments and I don't want to wave them away.
First, capital spending. Alphabet guided to roughly $91 billion to $93 billion in capex for 2025, which is an enormous bet that AI infrastructure pays for itself. If it doesn't, that money is gone and the depreciation line keeps climbing regardless. Second, antitrust. The remedy stopped short of forcing a Chrome sale, granted, but the default search deals that fed the machine took a real hit. Wall Street hasn't fully worked out what that costs over a decade.
Stack those two together with the possibility that AI answers compress ad pricing, and you can build a reasonable case for $250 or lower.
Color me skeptical, but that case usually overshoots. Every platform transition of the last twenty years was supposed to gut the incumbent's cash cow. History suggests otherwise. Google shipped its own AI answers, owns the distribution, and still controls the default on Android and Chrome.
My Verdict
Here's where I land. The valuation at $272.66 is the argument. Williams' two signals are a footnote. A stock that's given up nearly 20% in a month while the underlying ad business still prints cash is worth owning for patient money, and Alphabet's forward multiple sits near the bottom of its five-year range.
But I'm not entirely convinced the bottom is in. Momentum names rarely stop at neat numbers, and the AI-overhang narrative has another two or three earnings cycles to run before anyone knows whether it's real.
What to watch: fourth-quarter ad revenue, capex guidance for 2026, and any sign of actual erosion in Search query volume. If those three come in clean, the chartists will look smart. If they don't, the chart didn't matter anyway. Time will tell, though.
Related Articles
Explore More
Key Terms Explained
A company's profits, typically reported quarterly.
An indicator that smooths out price data by calculating the average price over a specific period.
A sustained increase in prices after a period of decline or consolidation.
Total income generated by a company or protocol before expenses.