S&P Hands Tether a 5 Out of 5, and Tether Answers With The Big Short
S&P Global's latest Stablecoin Stability Assessment left USDT parked at 5, the weakest score on a 1-to-5 scale. Tether didn't respond with an audit. It responded with a movie reference about traders who saw the mortgage crash coming while the rating agencies didn't.
S&P Global's latest Stablecoin Stability Assessment kept Tether's USDT at a 5. That's the bottom of the scale. There's no rung below it, so a "no change" verdict is still a verdict.
The scale runs from 1 to 5. One means very strong. Five means weak. USDT has been sitting on the floor, and the raters saw no reason to move it this round.
Tether's reply wasn't a data dump. It was a movie reference. The company invoked The Big Short, the 2015 film about the traders who bet against mortgage-backed securities and got rich while the rating agencies kept stamping AAA on garbage. The message isn't subtle. Tether is saying the people holding the scorecards are the ones who missed it in 2008.
Fair point. Also a dodge.
The rating isn't really about whether USDT breaks. It's about what's behind it. Tether publishes attestations, not full audits, and its reserves carry gold, bitcoin and secured loans alongside more than $100 billion in US Treasuries. Those first three lines are what S&. P doesn't like. A Treasury bill is a Treasury bill. A secured loan to an unnamed counterparty is a conversation.
But here's what the score misses. In Buenos Aires, stablecoins aren't speculation. They're survival. Same story in Caracas, and increasingly in Lagos. USDT moves more peer-to-peer volume through Latin America's remittance corridors than any bank-issued dollar product, and it settles on a Sunday. Nobody in that corridor pulls up a ratings report before sending money home to their mother.
So both sides have a case, which is the annoying part. Tether's transparency has real gaps, and the agencies have a track record of being confidently late.
Watch the audit. Tether has promised a full one for years. Deliver it and the 5 becomes a 3 without a single press release.
Key Terms Explained
The first cryptocurrency, created in 2009 by the pseudonymous Satoshi Nakamoto.
A sudden, significant price drop usually caused by large sell-offs.
Buying assets hoping to profit from price changes rather than fundamental value.
A cryptocurrency designed to maintain a stable value, usually pegged to the US dollar.