Bitwise Wants In-Kind ZEC Redemptions. Grayscale's $489M Zcash Fund Says Cash Only.
Two spot Zcash ETFs, same asset, opposite redemption plumbing. Bitwise is pushing physical ZEC delivery for authorized participants while Grayscale's quarterly filing locks its $489 million vehicle into cash redemptions. The structure, not the coin, is the story.
Two spot Zcash ETFs, one asset, and two completely different redemption rails. Bitwise's proposal would let authorized participants take physical delivery of ZEC when they exit. Grayscale's quarterly filing says plainly that its Zcash trust requires cash redemptions. Same coin. Opposite plumbing.
That gap isn't cosmetic. In-kind redemption keeps a fund tethered to the underlying market, because APs hand back shares and receive the actual asset. Cash redemption forces the issuer to sell ZEC to raise the money, then distribute it. Every one of those steps adds spread, slippage, and a taxable event. On a thin order book, that's exactly how a fund drifts away from its NAV.
Grayscale's Zcash vehicle carries roughly $489 million. That's a lot of weight resting on a cash-only rail. And the real bottleneck isn't the coin, it's the exit. ZEC doesn't have the depth of BTC or ETH, so the moment redemptions pick up, the issuer becomes the seller. Bitwise is arguing, in effect, that the structure should absorb that pressure instead of the market.
Here's the part people skip. In-kind creation and redemption is the mechanic that made spot bitcoin ETFs function, and it's what keeps arbitrage spreads tight. Strip it out and you've built a fund that trades at a premium in good weeks and a discount in bad ones. For a privacy asset, where liquidity is already the constraint, cash-only is the harder path to walk.
So Bitwise picks up a marketing edge here regardless of how regulators look at it. It can tell allocators its product has the cleaner arbitrage loop, and that pitch lands with anyone who's watched a trust trade sideways to its book value for a year.
Watch the AP list. If the desks that make markets in ZEC line up behind the in-kind structure, that says more about which fund survives than any filing will.
Key Terms Explained
Profiting from price differences of the same asset across different markets.
The first cryptocurrency, created in 2009 by the pseudonymous Satoshi Nakamoto.
How easily an asset can be bought or sold without significantly affecting its price.
A list of all buy and sell orders for an asset, organized by price.